Skip to article
← Back to Blog
Marketing, SEO

How to Choose Which Restaurant Reviews to Show on Your Website

By Fleksa7 min read•Restaurant Websites, Customer Reviews, Restaurant Marketing

A good review can help a guest decide where to eat, but displaying it takes more than copying a compliment. Use this process to check permission, preserve context, document approvals, and retire claims that no longer fit.

Choose reviews that describe a real guest experience, have a traceable source, and can be displayed with the required permission and attribution. Before publishing, read the full review for context and check whether its claims still fit the restaurant. Keep a record of each decision so someone can update or remove the quote later.

The goal is a useful, accurate picture of the guest experience. A short quote about a friendly server may be easier to support than a broad promise that every meal arrives quickly. Both can be positive, but they carry different risks when placed on your website.

Confirm permission and platform display terms

Start with the source. A review might come from a public review platform, a direct email, a comment card, or a message sent to your restaurant. Being able to read a review publicly does not, by itself, answer whether you can copy it into your own marketing.

For each candidate, identify who wrote it, where it appeared, and what permission or display terms apply. A platform may offer a display method with its own conditions. A guest may agree to have a direct message quoted, but that permission should specify what you plan to show. If a platform's terms or the scope of a guest's permission are unclear, resolve the question before publishing. Ask a qualified adviser when you need help interpreting rights or contract terms.

Give the people involved clear jobs:

  • The manager selects candidates and checks that the experience described still makes sense.
  • The person managing the website checks the proposed display method, attribution, and ability to make changes.
  • The owner or designated approver records the decision and resolves questions about permission or sensitive claims.

When asking a guest for permission, share the exact words, the proposed name or identifier, and where the quote will appear. Keep the response with the source record. If the guest agrees to a first name only, do not add a last name or photo later without checking.

Also ask your website provider whether reviews are entered manually or displayed through a third-party tool. Can you choose which entries appear? Can you remove one promptly? Does the display method change or add attribution? Get answers for the actual setup, rather than assuming every review widget works the same way.

Attribute reviews accurately and preserve their meaning

Show the reviewer's name or approved identifier, source, and date when required by the applicable terms or permission. Even when a date is not required, it can help guests understand how recent an experience was. Use the date of the review, not the date you added it to the website, unless you clearly label both.

A quote can be short without being misleading. Read the complete review before selecting a sentence. Do not correct a review by adding praise the guest did not write, or remove words that change what the guest meant. If an excerpt omits material context, choose a different passage or do not use the review.

Hypothetical example: A guest writes, “The soup was excellent, though we waited a long time for our table.” The restaurant wants to promote its food and quick seating. Quoting “The soup was excellent” beside a soup photo may accurately reflect the food comment if permission and display terms allow that excerpt. Placing the same quote under a heading promising fast seating would suggest support for a claim the full review contradicts.

A review of one visit also does not prove a consistent result. Avoid turning “Our server handled my allergy question carefully” into “We can accommodate every allergy.” Keep the guest's words tied to that experience, and make any broader service statement separately and only if the restaurant can support it. For questions about specific dietary needs, invite guests to contact the restaurant rather than treating a review as a guarantee.

Think about the mix, too. Selecting positive reviews is normal for a restaurant website, but a collection of carefully cropped praise should not create a false impression about a menu item, service, or location. Pick comments about different genuine aspects of the visit, and avoid presenting old feedback about a closed location as if it describes the current one.

Use a provenance and approval log

A simple shared log makes each quote traceable. Store the full original review or a reliable reference to it, the proposed excerpt, and the permission record in a place the people responsible for the website can access. Limit access to guest contact details to staff who need them.

The table below shows what an approval record might contain. The entries are hypothetical; permission and display rules must be checked for each real review. A production log should also record the approver, approval date, website location, next review date, and any later change or removal.

Candidate and sourceProposed displayPermission and context checkDecision
Guest email about a birthday dinnerShort quote, first name, month and yearGuest agrees to those words and that attribution; full email supports the excerptApproved by manager; review after menu changes
Public platform review praising soup but noting a long waitFood quote beside the soup itemConfirm the platform's display terms; do not pair the quote with a fast-seating claimHold until display method is cleared
Old comment card praising a discontinued lunch specialQuote on the current lunch pageSource is identifiable, but the item no longer existsDo not publish on the current menu page

Make the decision field specific. “Approved” should mean the chosen wording, attribution, placement, and display method were approved—not that the quote can be reused anywhere forever. If the website team wants to put it in an advertisement or add a guest photo, check whether the existing permission covers that use.

Include a link or reference to the live page in the log. That helps the next manager find every placement when a guest requests a change or a claim becomes stale. If a tool displays reviews dynamically, document who controls its settings and how an individual review can be excluded or removed.

Review and remove outdated claims

Set a regular review date for the quotes on your site, and check them sooner when the restaurant makes a meaningful change. A new chef, changed hours, a discontinued dish, a renovation, or a move can make an otherwise genuine review confusing. The question is not whether the guest was truthful at the time; it is whether the quote still gives a fair impression now.

During each check, open the live page on a phone and a desktop. Confirm the quote matches the approved version, attribution is visible, and the surrounding heading or image does not imply more than the review says. Follow any link to the source if your display method includes one. Record the result and the next check date.

Give staff a straightforward removal path. Decide who receives a guest request, who can edit the website, and who confirms the quote has disappeared from each known placement. If a third-party display is involved, ask its provider how removal works and how long a change may take. Keep a dated note of the request and action rather than silently deleting the approval history.

If the source review changes or disappears, pause and reassess the website quote. The right response depends on the permission and display method. Do not assume that a quote copied months ago is still suitable simply because it was once approved.

Check your website controls before publishing

Your process depends on what you can actually edit. Ask whether you can change a quote, its heading, attribution, and page placement without rebuilding the page. Check who has access and whether the provider can help if the person who originally built the site is no longer available. The domain ownership guide covers another part of keeping control of your site.

Keep reviews relevant to the page. A comment about a dining room may help on a reservations page, while a comment about a particular dish belongs near that dish if it is still offered. A review about dining in should not be presented as evidence of an online ordering experience the guest did not describe.

If you are considering a new provider, use the restaurant website builder comparison alongside your review checklist. Ask each provider to explain how its actual setup handles manual quotes, third-party displays, mobile presentation, and removal. A product demonstration can show the editing steps without publishing a guest's review.

Next, choose one review already on your site and complete the log for it. Check the source, permission, full context, attribution, placement, and removal owner. Then ask Fleksa about its restaurant website, including current US availability and how your preferred review display would be managed.

Frequently asked questions

Can I copy any public review onto my restaurant website?

Do not assume public visibility gives you permission to copy it. Check the source platform's display terms and any permission needed from the reviewer before publishing.

Can I shorten a guest's review?

An excerpt may be useful if the applicable terms and permission allow it and the shortened text preserves the original meaning. Read the full review and check the surrounding heading and image for misleading context.

How often should I check displayed reviews?

Set a recurring review date that your team can maintain, and check sooner after meaningful changes to the menu, location, or service. Record who checked each quote and what action they took.

Ready to grow your restaurant?

Explore how Fleksa can support ordering and operations in your restaurant.